THE KNYVETT CASE.

Dominion, Volume 3, Issue 866, 12 July 1910, Page 5

THE KNYVETT CASE.

There is every indication that the clause in the Defence Act Amendment Bill, which makes provision lor the hearing of appeals by commissioned and non-com-missioned officers dismissed from the force, will be the subject of keen debate when before the House. The majority of members who are concerned to secure a fresh trial for Mr. Knyvett express satisfaction with the provision, but some southern members express dissatisfaction, at the setting up of an Appeal Board. Others declare that they would not oppose the clause if its retrospective effect was not limited to twelve months, so as practically to take in. only the Knyrett case. Others again declare that the introduction of a civil element on the board will be subversive of discipline, and is inconsistent. Mr. T. E. Taylor, member for Christchurch North, holds that not only officers but all ranks should have the right of appeal against dismissal. Hβ intends to movo in that direction when the clause is before the House. As far as the board is concerned, he finds no fault with it, but thinks its constitution is somewhat elaborate. He would have been content if the right of appeal had been to a Stipendiary Magistrate. Questioned yesterday as to whether the commandant, when ho arrives, would take any part in the retrial of Captain. Knyvett, tho Prime Minister said the appeal would be heard, not by the commandant, but by the board set up for that purpose undor tho Bill.