REMARKABLE CASE OF MISTAKEN IDENTITY.
j^WpVsmp-st^et Pplw |yer; ':%2'Z ijp/pathan Abbott/ a;/r^pectable; lpp^ing/ypupg mari/pf; about 21./ca^ on refnaridi,' charged orif suspicion ;^ with.lthe;. ; folio wing-xobberyi-rr"/;/ ;j//At!;''the;ffirstex^n^^ 'aeryanlt^pf'Mir/^me^ In/yHigh-sft^ iipprf /going: upstairsy at-/ nal^paet /jU)-/pn; Sunday-umprriingi; ih /cbnsejquericef; pf yhlicj maMesr's; dogtbaHcihg/f very violently; $^ fouhii ■ the fdrawers yinf the; sitting-room; which; shefkriew to have been'elosed before,' all widia open, and/ on 'lobkingyover the JDannisters she saw the;prisprier cpniing* frbrri the/diriirig-rbom/with" the'piate-basket, m/his )|and/ " She/ ym downstairsi aftephim;, c/klliHg s 'upon hirrif tp ; saj*/who he^a^ and; the/prison er ran i hto/ tiie b^edrpem,/ fp7 J owed; by >the/f.witriess; who Ibuss off the /drawers, pre^hteJitat'/hiTh, and/ declared she -would; rshpotj/him if h,e.; didyhot giye up. the; plate..yThe;prisoner:; hesitiited to dp so, and she preseritedfthe blunderbuss at himand pulled the trigger; but the.lock only .snapped, without tlie piece! ;explpdirig/ and yishei ■ therefore; fliiiig; the ;piece/down;'closed;;wi;th;^he;prisorier; andsiiat^ed/the fpite-basket away {fprnhirri/ :Tl^/instant f she/ha 1 /done sq; the prisoWer turried/sliarply' round,/leaped, through the ; bed^rpp/m fwindow oh to sompjtiles, an,(| fpr, ItlVaOiithe escaped. On Tuesday mornjhg^ Ayhiler ; .passiing thrpugh:thpvHackney-i;oad/ ;slip .saw ;thp v prispAer enter a;publicThouse,, identified hini immed|<itely, and rap; for, a policerrian j to ■take, him, hut when she/had.. rgot; backi ;with? an officer-hehadlefV;yshe ' subsequently, however; saw him in, front of a waxwork exhibition' in the.same neighborhood, and;was this time more successful ;iii/securing him:' She; did not/get afull Vi/eiv of the;prisonefa face, but she was close to ..him when s^e wrested thp^plate-' basket ffroihyhim, aiidycpuld/gwearhabst positively to.him, /both ffro^'liis/ personal appearance ,a,nd.r di*ess,,.;he thayihg/pip the ; same !.4ap 7 and coat he •np\y^"wpr^.,/.thp / pnly. ■ difference. being ; ,that he. : ,then wpre a pair of shepherd's; pi aid,^trousers. The girl; was repeatedly cautioned as to the possibility of hetf being mistaken in the:- prisoner, but she declared she was perfectly cool at the time/arid in flexibly adhered to her idehtificatiph of hifti; in which1 she was most positive, andcouTd riptbe deceiyed.f y f y A ■■■"■'■ yf- / Mr. Sheltpn said he was attending service with his family at/0/ ; City-irpad, Chapel/dh Sunday morning, /w;hen he/ wias suddenly sehtfor, and. on getting .home, found hjs house had, bpen.entered.'through the.;kit-chen-dpor.or \vindo.vy' by c .thieves, Avho had broken'open;his counting-house,desk with a.crow bar, and also idrawers yin ..-.both., his daughter's and his niece's bed-rooms.. The platen-basket had been saved through the Courage of -the girl Everett, but ;the thieves had still got off with a gold watch, three gold seals, a gold pencil-case, three gold earrings; ai silver watch,y.and several other articles, none of wbieh had sinceheen either;,., traepd. or reeovered.f It wa? quite by.accident'Or j pi-oviderice that the. blun-. derbuss was at •that, timef^nlpa.ded, as he always kept it loaded ; fbr^the : protection ofhis premises,;which had/<>been several times attempted. #; ,-.-.. -,-.. -, /f y; '-. -X In ansvver to this posi tive -testimony ■ the prisoner called his father, John Abbott, > who .declared1 that his: son was perfectly; innocent; that he knew him to be so, andi could, .moreover, as fortune would have; it;produce 200 witnesses, if necessary, .to \ prove that he was so. On tlie Sunday; morning the prisoner got up at :half-past s $, and he nevt;r lost sight of him for more than a n}inute or. two at fa , time till the same hour >at .Bight. In the niorning.;he vvvpre",vjiipt : :the,;coat-,iie. now, had on, but a waistcoat; \yith:sleeve's;. ; tpyi.t, and; wore this;till he' dressed for, chapel, whpn he 'wore a black frock coat, dark brown trou-| sers, knd a black alpaca waistcoat, and he; never hadplaid trousers iri his life.3 The chapel; is two miles from the prosecutor's;premises ;|. the prisoner was dressed" for chapel at a; little/pastlG, arid was in chapel at halF-' past; 10. The witness hiniself had been 18 years, iri his present -si tuaiion> ; , and four /yearSjan atteniilantat; thisjchapel, ,He was rnpst anxious :-tp.- : have;,the//.vyholi3f.matter thoroughly in vestigated, as it was most distressing to thef;family,yand,:must prove his son's entire innocence. ; : > The girl•Fiverettiwas:again called and cautioned,; but said-—" I can< and do swear most positively to him, andyam quite sure he is the same man." ' ' f / f^ !f The ; case was, therefore; adjourned till Friday,; when /the' court /was crowded with respectable persons, / thef majority of them / witnesses for/the prisoner,; who/. appeared ;j quite distracted with his situation/was more \ than once in tears, and buried his faee./ih' 'hisrhatids. //;//,./;:..../ ..../ ~;;;/:■/;/-.! '; ..././Qafcbign, of /the. : ll division, t aaidyhef ; knew a regular thief ,whp very much resera|bled the prisoner indeed, and he did -not; believe thef prispner was guilty; and/two/ other 'officers said precisely the samef/ff y I ; /The girl was therefore again asked the same question a,s before;' and replied, in j answer to the 01^81^16^'Thre-thief did ; i not speak a word, but/I am certain .prisoner is the same/mati. I. was quite/ t collected tlie / tiiiie, would h^ve/shot/ hira/J if/the/blrihderbus^.^ unjbaded, . r and would have pinned hirii^ to the/^indow|-, sill if I had hacl one bftheriieat-spearshe^r :^e:."''///'///;/y.///.f;/,,/.; 'xZ-AZxa-aZ}-^ U .Out of at t least two idpzen witnesses wli|j j were anxious to he exaniipedr for : thecpti,-! j gpher, three, named iGireeri,;:Griffiths^.;ahjjifl Hawking the; litter the^chapely organist^] V^ere seilecled, threfe sworethatpi*^ seiner attended all the services atthecliapfl tlut/clay/and/wasf.therei MYp!Y pe^itiihe; 'nio/rhihg at' 20' or 25 minutes past 10. and was recognised, nodded to, and spoken to :; tty3%M/;.// '/: " ' YXAyslt!._ IJ'Jiyhcburf said, that ( no evidence could be stronger or more positive than this; the young woman, cool and ,positive aa she was,; must be mistaken, and the prigoner must be discharged. , ,
Permanent link to this item
Hononga pūmau ki tēnei tūemi
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/TC18590322.2.12
Bibliographic details
Ngā taipitopito pukapuka
Colonist, Volume II, Issue 148, 22 March 1859, Page 4
Word count
Tapeke kupu
889REMARKABLE CASE OF MISTAKEN IDENTITY. Colonist, Volume II, Issue 148, 22 March 1859, Page 4
Using this item
Te whakamahi i tēnei tūemi
No known copyright (New Zealand)
To the best of the National Library of New Zealand’s knowledge, under New Zealand law, there is no copyright in this item in New Zealand.
You can copy this item, share it, and post it on a blog or website. It can be modified, remixed and built upon. It can be used commercially. If reproducing this item, it is helpful to include the source.
For further information please refer to the Copyright guide.