The Oamaru Times And Waitaki Reporter Thursday, April 21,1864
The adverse vote on the second
reading of Mr.Dick’s Indemnity
Bill by the Provincial Council
on Friday Last which resulted
m the resignation of the Excu-
-tive, is an Event of much quat-
-er significance than it seems
to be generally consideed.
We observe that out contim-
-poraries m commnenting on the
Event ,regard it as calculat-
-ed to work out good for the
Province.lt is however,but
one more added to the list of
failures already achieved,
“and then an End”.The Ex-
-ecutive must be shown that
it cannot spend money with
Impunity and plunge the
communtiy m debt.Still there
are other political complicat-
-tions of the case to be adjusted
of perhaps greater importance.
just now. Let it be granted
that the vote given by the Pro-
-vincial Council was a perfect-
-ly consecentious one –that
nothing but the purest patrio-
-tism moved Mr Yogel m his
Opposition –and that the
Council has an undoubted
right to suspend or reject any
measures before it which it may
deem to be detrimental to the
public intersts. Still there are
limits even to the discretionary
action of the Provincial Coun
-cil-limits not imposed m
deed, by the Letter of Constrituti-
-onal law, but never the less
zeal and salutary.When the
Executive has Expended certain
monies absolutely required by
the wigencies of the state, Even
wthout the cousent of the Pro-
-incial Council,the council
ought to have very solid grounds
of objection to proceed upon
before it adopt such a course
as it ded on Friday last.lt
must not use its power to place
an insurmountable barrier
m the way of just and needful
Executive adminstraiton. It
must not create dead-locks m
the course of public affairs.
It must not by a too free use of
its right of veto indirectly stimu-
-late and Encourage unnecessary
popular agitation .The council
should know when to concede as
well as when to reject,otherwise
it will entirely misapply its fune-
-tions;and from being an indus-
-pensible and valuable part of our
system of governement it will
become and intolerable obstructi-
-on and grievance.
Now the Council we think went
rather beyond the limits pointed
out m their vote on the Indem-
nity Bill.The necessities of the
country urgently demanded that
it should pass at any rate.its sec-
-and reading before the Mail clo-
-sed for England under such a
circumstance it was clearly the
duty of the council to pass the
Prill before it-at any rate not to
suspend its progress so premature-
-ly. But by this vote the Council
have not alone suspended the
progress of public business ,but
left the Province without a govern-
ment –at the present crisis a most
serious atate of things –and par-
-ticularly so.since there is some
doubts as to wheather there is mate-
-rials among the Opposition party
to form a solid Administration.
The result however of this undue
Excerise of power ,have still to be
developed.lf the Dick Ministry
do not go back to office and delay
be occasionaed m the formation of
a new executive a smart colli-
sion between the Council and the
people is sure to be the result.
There is no un settled public ques-
-tion Easier of Equtiable adjust-
-ment than the squalting queation
if only the interests of insitive and the
Permanet benefit of the Province
be taken into account .All that
is required to be done,infact is to
determine the limitations of the
lesiure of the present pastoral
tenauts of the crown on such gro-
-unds as simple justice and equi-
-ty dictate .If past administrations
had but honestly recognized this
fact and acted on it ,things would
not be as they are now .The land
question will compose one of the
many to be discussed during the pre-
-sent sitting of the council let them
the present ministry recognize tis
principle m their delibertions
and m all probibility the difficulty
Will erase to be.
The fact is the great evil m Con-
-nection with out Land Laws m gen-
-eral and with the squatting ques-
-tions m particulars has been that of
over –legislation. It is a fixed
principle m the science of legisla-
tion that the less artifical laws are
the better will they be understood
And the more easily will they be
carried out. In regard to many
things there is far more injury
done by over –legislation than by
no legislation at all. Like a patient
for whose malady as many diffe-
-rent remedies are recommanded
as there are physicians called m ,so
is it m matters of state. From
the sheer multiplicity of doses and
their opposite Effects on his cons-
-titution, the poor patient dies at
length –doctorial to death.
were he but let judiciously alone,
m almost every case through the
Mr. medicatorix natura, he would
Probably recovver. Homoeopathy
wins the day by its infimatesimals
that is to say by letting alone.
To enact that settlers shall have
no better tennres to their runs than
they now have –which by the way
amounts to none at asll –is to
legislate m sheerfully. Capital is
permetically sealed up,or sent
beyond the Province. The result of
this is gricuously felt by all sections
of the community m the absence
of the community m the absence
stapel articles of food and
many other ways .In short to
no other surce can the woes
which now afflict the Province
be logically attributed but the
land regulations which have
existed for years past .It is to be
hoped therefore that mr.Dick and
his friends have come to discern
fully the evils of the present land
law and the necessity of affording
greater encourgement to pas-
-toral settlement.
If the settlers were guaranteed
the use of their runs until they
should be required for agri-
-cultural and occuption .they would
be satisfied and from our know-
-ledge of them we venture to Bay,
very few of them would be inclianed
to stand m the way of bonafidi
settlement. Look for example
at the North and North West
angle of the Province.No per-
-son not utterly ignorant of that
country and man upon a land
theory of his own would ever dre-
-am of the settlement of this portion
of our territory as and Eligible
field for agricultural. To begin
with it contains a vast area
where nothing can live and that
portion adopted for agraicultural
purposes is so far from a market
that the cost of transit would be
more than the value of the produce
when brought to market.lt will
therefore be a long time before such
a country can be of any use for
agricultural purposes morever
much of the land on the seaboard
is valuless for such uses through
the same cause. Before them the
land can be used for agricultural
purposes trunk lines of commu-
-nications must be opened up.
(railways or metalled raods)
connecting the inalnd districts.
with the sea ports.
Further of the Entire community
the sqnatters are certainly the
least expensive to the government.
The revenue desired from the
Gold-fields and by tariiff is nearly
all swallowed up m provinding
roads and bridges, notices estab-
-lishments and the general ap-
-parates of local government.
In the pastrol districts ,there
are few roads and bridges.
Police are very flew because they are
not needed and the expense of
getting the license –fees and as-
-sessments m nearly nothing at
all.lt is undeniably true that
squatting pays well but neither
are all squatters wealthy men.
Many of them were once shepherds
and hard-workinh men.others
were overeseas and many of these
two classes are still struggling to
rise to a position of indepndence. These are plain and palpable facts, which all fairness and
justice must be taken into ac-
count m rightly adjusting the
conditions of pastrol tenants
lenure.The clear apprehension
and frank recognition of them
will for mr.Dick and miscollea-
-gues help vastly to bring to a
logical and permanent solution
and settlement of the question.
Let the settlers be made to pay a
full and fair rent for their
rims but let us hence forth and
for ever fors wear all conventi-
-onist crotchets and chass legis-
-lation .Let us have honest men
of patriotic and simple aims to
rule over us. Let the spirit of just
and fair dealing with all sections
of the community the recognition
of righteous claims and the promo-
tion of all good measures be the
dominant motives of the present
Ministry and it will not
alone be able to surmount and
settle the Land question success-
-fully but all others that now
press upon the interests of Otago.
[The above was m type before
the news of the resignations of the
Dick adminstration reached us.]
We take the following important
paragraph from mr. Fames Hornis
report to the committee of the
Oamaru Anti-Pleuro-pnermonia
Association dated the 18th instant
at palmerston –“I have the honor
to report that mr Jones’cattle at
Waikianiti have beem mustered
and having inspected them along
with mr Bust I am sorry to say the
among them. I have no hesitation
m saying that m a mob of about
a hundred head which I saw col-
-lected ,one-third are more or less
affective and twelve so badly that
they are to be destroyed either to-
-day or to marrow.. will the gentle-
-men m Dunedin and thye infected
district who are now during their
Atmost to have the present bound
-aries broken down m the face of
such facts as these continue to
large their selfish and unjusti-
-fiable demand ? In another
part of the same reports mr.Horne
remarks:- “I am glad on the other
haad to have to reports that at the
a careful examination of mr.
orbell’s molo.we known them a just
deal improved .There are a few
sickleyness among then but no
bad cases.As to the Respass of his
(Mr Orbell’s cattle the matter so her
as it has gone has been the means
Trousing the peopleou the Waikau-
-aiti side to look better after their
Cattle”
A bill has passed both Houses:-
the Syding Legislative prohibiting
the Exportation of diseased cattle.
The remains of mr. Griffiths,
Who lost his life while crosssing the
Waitaki River tow years ago were
Brought into town on Friday last
And on Sunday were interect.
Many old axquantances and
Friends followed them to the grave.
The Rev.A Gifford officiated.
and after reading the service de-
-livered a most impresive address
On the uncertainly & life refering
frequently to the decreased and the
accidently through which he passed
From time.
It seems that the efforts of the
Estimable Presbyterian Cl;ergymen of this dis-
-trict (the rev Charles Connor at
The Dunedin are likey to such
In some thing permanent before
Long. In the report of a meeting
held ast that infece .on the 15th isnatant
the Dunedin Times had the hol-
-lowing –“ A number of gentlemen
were fornmed into a communities.
with whom the Presybtery at dunedin
Will communicate on all matters
realting to the cause of Presbyte
-rianism .Great hopes are entertain-
Ed that a minister of the denomui-
nation will shortly be appointed
for the district.
Since the discovery of the gold
fields m thois province m 1861,
1,462,503 ownces have been exported
During the current year up to the
6th instant 129,427 ounces 10 dwls.
have been brpught down by 20 cart
and 176,500 ounces hsve been exported.
If would seem from thre following
paragrpahs extracted from the
Waikitip Mail that an Extcicinet and
Cheap means of making the New
Zealand Flay of Commercial value
has been discovered by a resident
at Dunedin shown :- “Amongst the
discoveries recently made known is
one by our follows townsman mr
Procler ,who has invented an easy
and rapid mode of dressinf flag.
The samples exhibited are very well
got up and mr Procter states that
the Operation of dressing rely oc-
cupies one hour mr/ Stewart since
this fact was piblished has called
at our office and informed us that
he also has discovered a method
of dressing the flag.
On Tuesday last there was a riot
among the roadmen at the white
swamp near Hawkesburg which
for a time promised to end seriously
The police however soon arrived on the
Spot and arrested the ring leader
and soon after the men retured gui-
-ettly to their work.The cause of the
affray we have not bee b able to learn.
The man Jones alias Old Sam
Who robbef mr Fraser nea Waikou-
-aiti on 8 th instant were arrested
a port Chalmers on Monday last.
Little money was found on him.
He had however m his possession
alife preserver .He made little
reistance and was therefore capture-
-ed more easily than was audance-
-cd. The Daily Times of yestersday
says:- Samuel Jones alias Old
Sam was yeasterday brought before
the Resident Magistrate on a charge
of hearing asaulted are robbed mr
James Fruser on the Waikiuaiti
road m the Bth instant .The mr woner
was acommanded for four days m
from attractive for Provided to
arrive m town.
We have seen a sample of potatoes
And parsnips grown by mr Litle of
The Maerewhere Hotel macre whe-
-nua. They are without doubt the
largest and finest we have ever seen
and are positive evidence at the
producing capability of the land on thet
district mr Little informs that thr
gromer from which the sample of
potatoes was taken yieldfieds over
twelve tones per acre .He was spenldied
over £3000 m building m Hotel and
making other improvements on land
still government property and
would expend still more capital if
the land were his own .He has made
frequent applications to have the
land surveyed men should cer-
but success suermen should cer-
-tainly m couraged.
In private letter to the Wellington
Independent dated 6th instant it
W stated “ that review the nashing
Cheek of the privates has been ta-
Ken prisoners .He was severly
wounded m three palces. Two men
of the 40 the regt.found him lying
m a swamp and when they brought
him m they received 10 each for
taking him praivatore .It was ac-
-ported a the fronnt that the macris
are keep m a thomed on appered
amongst themselves and m we one
hundred men on guard over m
Every day because he isists upon
making peace and they won’t
agree to it but are datermined to
fight it out.”
It is Notified m our advertising
columous that section m block I
Papatioris will be upon for appli-
-cation on Thursday the STH imo-
proy and will be decided on Tues-
-day the 17th following. Vllaps of
the block describing Each section
may be had at the office of his paper
Permanent link to this item
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/NOT18640421.2.11
Bibliographic details
North Otago Times, Volume I, Issue 4, 21 April 1864, Page 4
Word Count
2,468The Oamaru Times And Waitaki Reporter Thursday, April 21,1864 North Otago Times, Volume I, Issue 4, 21 April 1864, Page 4
Using This Item
No known copyright (New Zealand)
To the best of the National Library of New Zealand’s knowledge, under New Zealand law, there is no copyright in this item in New Zealand.
You can copy this item, share it, and post it on a blog or website. It can be modified, remixed and built upon. It can be used commercially. If reproducing this item, it is helpful to include the source.
For further information please refer to the Copyright guide.