MARSHAL BAZAINE.
| The slow process of change in the ideas find characteristics of a nation is strongly exhibited in the passing history of France, When first the charge of treachery - was brought against Marshal Bazaine we were inclined to believe that it was only a political expedient, intended to divert popu~ llr indignation IfiromtKe" whb £ "*- possibly might contemplate msumingr his tlirone when opportunity offered. Sacriin the history of European wars. Our own country Has been disgi^Hby~Mini3~=~77 tries' throwing the blame.of their incom-S-i petency upon unsuccessful naval or mili-" tary officers; and either"exposing them, to almost - inevitable .death' if i they theif duty, as in the„case,of Sir John Moore; or to trial and execution as Admiral Byng. ' Increditableas--it may seem, there are~ no facts - better established-than - that both those eommanr ... "• ders were sacrificed ,by_the. Ministries -of the day, through, being expected to effect specific objects with very inadequate means..,, Moore fell honorably on the field af'terachievingavictorywhich"wasnearly*:.as disastrous as a defeat; while - Byng returned 1 to Britain after a gallant effort-Ion;a the part of his fleet, although it was said itweakly was participated in by his own vessels One ot his biographers informs us that popular " clamor, raised at Home, was more , directed against the Ministry, who had ',, neglected to fit out the fleet properly* than againsfr the. j Admiral, • who had fought languidly." " The intrigues of his po-"~-litical enemies" prevailed; the Press was - employed- against him; ..Mallet, an able but, venal- writer, led the' van ; and inspite of many representations'in hisfavor,' Byng was sentenced to be shot, but unarii- ~ tnously recommended as a proper object--mercy." The parallel between-his ease—' and that of Bazaine ceases with the sentence passed. "Byng acted" under 'orders in opposition to the unanimous opinion of '• a council ol war" that-it was impossible the object of the expedition—the' re- - lief - ofALinorca—could - bei effected-- t by the force under his command. He did - not attempt what proved impossible. BuP "Bazaine has not -been -able-to—i. prove that he acted'so. straightforward'a- - paft. The accounts of trial published in £ the leading journals, lead to the irresistible--conclusion-that he preferred his own) ajg—7a grandiwnent to that of-the Empire that lie served; and to advance his own interestshe, sacrificed the Emperor "his, army, and,his country. We do„not suppose * "that c3 ~ the political result of the war, so far at , Germany is concerned, would have been materially had he faithfully and . gallantly fulfilled his duty. The contest* might have been prolonged, and 'Paris 1 might have been more obstinately defended/- have been ; a greater sacrifice of German life in the reduction of„ Vletz and Paris;, but it is * also probable there .would not have been.-„ T a red revolution, and thai fewer political^ 1 P®'Pjp*ities would have arisen thaijhaye .since been found" so difficultTof The whole .history of the war 3 proves P' that the Government of Louis Napoleon—was a most-hollow affair, and that Himself was by seeking, '.unscrupulous men, ready sac-, rifice everything to secure their own ends. ■>< The Emperor an army, the chief use of which, during a greit part of' his reign,< was to keep in checklthe ments of disorder at Home, ready) to nurst their bonds'as- soon as the presswre that kept them down was removed. - His com-— ~ missariat, .that he. thought po^welfi organised, proved corrupt enough to (wink at contractors substituting cartridges! of sawl " dust for gunpowder, and thusexposing gallant men to inevitable defeat or death through depriving them of the ve*y mWn* on which they.. relied for . andhe " entrusted one of the most important com-r.u} mands to a man ready to riskhorior, famearmy, and Empire to his own [personal ambition. We do not believe that" the 1 Emperor of his own will would have entered upon a foreign war; but nofglory is " gained by, an army maintained] merely, forpurposesof. repression, and glorWisthe god of a military commander. "K 0 «itf — no glory" is his motto. The tr&itionai policy of European GovernmentTtq become great by crushing a neighbor no dduKt had something to do with the matter, but we cannot conclude otherwise th^n ; ' that Napoleon's chief object was to the *' army thoroughly to his dynasty, )ih the hope that no difficulty would preol'Vt:.- - self to his son's accession to the'throne. "■ ; We are inclined to this view frornthfr ■following remarkable passage 'in the the 'Union Medicate* of. July/ 1870: ." On July 1, 1870. the -Emperor Napoleon feeling very -ill, a consultation took place. between Doctors Nelaton. Ricord, Fayel. Corrisart, and See.- Their diag- ' n.osis was that of stone;~and ah immediate was ~ recommended.; from political.coiutderatiQiw ♦< ;was allowed to goonfortwo years and a hialf.'" The Emperor sacrificed himself to'the . interests of his son ; Bazaine sacrificed ajyi—Emperor, Empire. and army to servehimself Condemningwarasthegreat. est curse that can' fell* upon or , the world, so lorig as that curKrt endures, it is aggravated by dependent upon soldier for even' the trifling chance of escapefrom Wound or death thaVmodern; warfare affords,. a W desertion or cowardice by privates »" punishable with - death. We iknow no treason, whv wholesale desertion like-that induced, by Bazaine should be -more leniehtly • dealt with, or why greater consideration be shown to. the great delinquent than to •' the small-t -the selfishness in eacn is parallei, one exhibits it in an en- ' ileavor to escape from niilitary gervice r the. other in sacrificing frienas comrade* ' to:periS(mal * Star;*
Judge (to prisoner con vidid' of .grand » larceny)—" itave anything tJ offarto the *ouit before .sentence is'passed on- you ?I* •Prisoner, —"No, judge' j/mt;broke. chad ten dollars when I came', in here, but my-lawyer's got that-teu dcillar» 1
Permanent link to this item
Hononga pūmau ki tēnei tūemi
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MIC18740102.2.10
Bibliographic details
Ngā taipitopito pukapuka
Mount Ida Chronicle, Volume IV, Issue 252, 2 January 1874, Page 2
Word count
Tapeke kupu
919MARSHAL BAZAINE. Mount Ida Chronicle, Volume IV, Issue 252, 2 January 1874, Page 2
Using this item
Te whakamahi i tēnei tūemi
No known copyright (New Zealand)
To the best of the National Library of New Zealand’s knowledge, under New Zealand law, there is no copyright in this item in New Zealand.
You can copy this item, share it, and post it on a blog or website. It can be modified, remixed and built upon. It can be used commercially. If reproducing this item, it is helpful to include the source.
For further information please refer to the Copyright guide.