Thank you for correcting the text in this article. Your corrections improve Papers Past searches for everyone. See the latest corrections.

This article contains searchable text which was automatically generated and may contain errors. Join the community and correct any errors you spot to help us improve Papers Past.

Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image

JUSTICE IN BOLSHEVIK

AMAZING SCENE FROM A TRIAL V A COURT WITHOUT LAW ■ _"To allintentsand purposes it is practically impossible anywhere in Russia, to. try a civil oase,'\says a writer in the New York "Globe." , "Misdemeanours and dimes all fall , wider'the'jurisdiction of the local Soviet, and very little time is . . wasted 'in-legal formality.' If a-man is • detected in the act ofistealing, ho will probably find himself facing a firinerequad within an hour."- A few months ngo, General Boiderev, formerly Bulgn'rian Minister of War,,' : commanded the Fifth Russian Army,.which defended the ; positions- -north and; sonth : of- Dvinsk. ■■'~'When: ,t he Bolshevik- revolution- over- - threw .Kerensky, Krylenko was named to succeed General Boiderev ■asiommander- . ; in-chief . of .the' Russian' armies in the field. . Boiderev ; refused to . ..command and IvTylenkb issued a decree .to ; the, effect', that. officers Tefusin? ,t6 obey •the orders of-the new Bolshevik regime, issued through Krylenko, would be guilty . ,-of high treason..- General , Boiderev de- : liberately disobeyed Krylenko'iS orders. . . ..".'.. ~ . .Trial of .BoiderevT v ''■■■'". . .. -The-. "Globs" describes the , climax, of ; BoMerev's trial:-' , IV ''■■.'■"'■' "...','' .' .. ."Citizen Boiderev,stand up! ■ ■''' ;: ,■' . • 'Tlife Revolutionary Tribunal, deriving ' its powers from the ■ Droletafiat' 'of 'new: free Russia. , 'hereby 'finds yon guiltv ; of. . high .-treason and sentences you to tWee ' ;■ Tears','imprisonment at hnrd labour." ■ '-. ■ ' A moment of tense silence "was .by >a. woman's so , " .•..'Shn wns a 'relative .of the prisoner. ■ The jury heard tTio-'w"->n\an's::weepimr -sml nijnoared'nricomfpTtablo. The crowd heard and grew angry with the Coiirt.: The woman matliv ?evfiral atr.nmntsito: recover control, of herr. .■6°lf.-. -Finally; she 'blurted out. '• ..-ehome, is.this revolutionary justirp?". ■■'. ' ..;..-.The crowd took up the cries . shame, this trial is mockerylfhis cou'rt a .. travesty,".; Thp provident of flip court,'n . . .-roughly drp=*wl rroV «finMli<rpnt at> pearance, Tapped' loudly with his gavel .and tinkled a little bell, ■onllinp loudly. for order.. The 'crowd'paw , no utteipKo" to him. . The cries grew louder. The ■crowd became a mob. . The derisive yells, now.injixed , with, bitter, vicious -.cniws, went on unchecked. -The mob rapidly approncW. a etnf-n of fnmv. .The rireji- . .ripntrheld -up..-both hand?, but could not ' ■ compel silence. The crowd yelled' louder. A lull in the din finally came. The pre- . sident. threatened- the mob with ejection at the point of the bayonet, unless sile'nco '. wprn instnntaneously.Testnred. '■<'>'<• ' ' . ,The forty or'fifty spectators, now'an infuriated rabble, .swent toward the rostrum. intent, on- murder. ■■ Chair's and .tables were flung, aside. ! Wild yells echoed, throughout the.palace.) Men and 'women trampled on each 'other. Two or were drawn. The president of the Tribunal with the jury annpnjred ■ badly frightened, although, all held, firm.. i The president.pressed.a push button of ' -on ."iectr'o.bell:' Every .doorwns. flung .'.open,, and soldiers rushed in,'.bayonets . .'were, already fixed on their- rifles.■- The rattle and map of breech-bolts its live :'. cartridges were jammed home meantTiusin'ess. The mob heard the rattle-and . Knew its meaning from .past experience. ..That which an instant, before was madness of anger .'was now. the frenzy of-fear. : Women screamed and fainted. Men made . ■ ;■. wild rush for the doors. Every- 1 exit, was blocked by groups of soldiers with ' bayonets, at ready. ' ■ : ■ ■ < ':■■.■ .Like, frightened sheep,: the rioters cow- , ered together, in the centre of:the court for. means, of escapet.which did not exist.- Every where, that frantic eyes ■ .. . royed they saw bayonets and'the bright V-t'pl rims of: rifle : muzzles," The mob> ;felt fear and;stood . in •' trembling; < -It knew that in each .of these two score rifles were' five-.live bultets... Most of. . the men had an elementary knowledge:of • "'."firearms," «nd they knew that the boit : action which'loaded, the rifles, the" sound of'which had been'audibly, to ■ all above .' ;tho din; .had at- the..same -time, cocked-. -. the hammer. ' But of' all, every ■ epldier appeared: ready, and, even. anxious to .-hoot, if one could judge from'.Hie-car--.essing-way they fingered-,the triggers'.' ; Prayers and loud- appeals.-for'-mercy,-had quickly replaced the curses, arid!..cries tor blood.. .This ,is. not a- psychological study of fear.. It is simply a description . of a scene. .'• . . . ■ '■ .- • '.' ■V But X know ,now' what fear, is because I was, caught in that mad rush and etood. in the outer rim of that crowd,with;the ," of-a.rifle less than a foot from the pit of my etomach, with an angry, , cursing soldier, fingering the trigger. -• . "Comrades, citizens, you have forgotten . yourselves," said the president of the ' Court, . . - ..' -. , .■.(.■•■.- •'■■-•■. ■ 'All eyes turned toward him. He was no longer the .oppressor but the deliverer. -■-. He ordered the' soldiers to'march off the.prisoner the ringleader of the-disturbance.. When the. crowd found-that it was not going to be'shot • down in cold blood, it commenced a moro rational defence against' the Court's decision, : and. appeared somewhat embar- : Tessed for its display of feeling. Fifteen or twenty-men we're arrested and searched. ■'' Those on whom arnie were -found ■ wore'sent to tho Peter and Paul fortress. The others- were released and permitted • to return to the'court room. ■'■ ;The'above description is .more'.or.' , less typical of the scenes one can witness .'in. .revolutionary Russia.almost every.day.if he Roes-looking for them. Through;.the very nature of .the. political turnover, life in Eussia is at the best uncertain. Hardly a day passes. when this Revolutionary • Tribunal is in session that there dpe3:not ■ occur eome such incident. ~'. ■''... . I ' The Soviet Court. ' There is something 6ingularly consistent in the fact that,'this Court, where a trial is likely to be rather a legal riot than dry judicial, procedure, sits in-a small ballroom of the new palace.of the Grand Duke Nicholas, the former com-mander-in-chief of the : Euseian , Army. Some fine paintings formerly hung on the walls, but ths decorations were torn down, along with great piecee of plastering. This was further to democratise the first Court of- Justice of EnssiVs revolutionary, proletariat, " . .. •. .. , ~-.- Five, or.-,six. rows of -bare, i backless ■' wcaden benches: will accommodate one hundred spectatore;: Smoking is permitted, and— ..' •...'■' -. - - ,-■ ■, After -half :'.an. hoiir'e session tho air ■is blue and the president and prisoner, who are hardly, twenty feet away,, are almost blurred outlines.- A press table / occupies a prominent position near the jury 3 table. ■■ The. Ilussian journalists al- ' ready have begun to .refer to themselves as the fourth estate. One , hears frequent remarks which indicate that as a cluss they have begun' a ' tardy study of tho French Revolution. The press correspondents in the Court passed a resolution that -they would -not smoke- while sitting at the press table. ' - ■■ . The court consists of six men, three workmen, two soldiers, and a sailor,' be-sides-ttho; president, -who-'votes' only in the event ..'of "a deadlock, although the president,, because of his superior ediicd- '. tionj' can "usually ewing the •verdict tho . way he wishes it to go. The president with hie juryi sits, on a low platform behind a long, straig-ht , table made, from Tough- planks-and-covered with cheap, red cotton cloth;' Six: or.'eight, candles affixed'to the table-with-melted tallow, or stuck into the necks of bottles, furnish light, for owing to the coal 'Shortage in -Petrograd the electric light'plants operate only between 7.30 in the' evening and midnight;'-- .-;■■.•;■• v: ■ Justice in this revolutionary court is ■ highly "primitive. A .majority- decision rules. The theory ■ is . that these workmen- and ■sbldiers > \jill , hear the evidence and trust their consciences' to render a just decision, regardless : 'of" legal , formalities. ■> There. ■ are no lawyers, .nor'-law booke; nor court proceedings.' It is'all so 'simple. Is the man guilt}-, yes or no His own, word on the question very often suffices. , ■ Cross-examination is conducted by the president. -Two witnesses • for the prosecution and two for tho defence are" all that are allowed. It is essentially a court for 'trying political crimes, "which term,: as broadly construed by the Soviet, includes any activities seeking to undermine the power of the Soviet-regime. .-;. • ' My first vieit tp the Revolutionary Tribunal was on the day of General Bolderev's trial. After the crowd had become quiet, I asked my interpreter. ' if he thought it possible that I could have a talk with the president of the court. The Interpreter said he would write a note

r - to him in Russian. .The note simply "■ stated that I was an American correspondent and requested an interview. The president looked lover toward us and smiled, and then wrote ft note. An armed soldier brought the note to us across : the court-room and handed it to my interpreter. He handed it to me. It was written in• perfectly good English. The. . president invited me'to the private juryroom after the adjournment of the court \ to "have a cup-qf ; tea and talk it over." - After I hnd -met tho o.ther members of the court and said to them a few words on America's interest in the welfare of ' the Russian people! the, president, whose } name was Zurin, which is incidentally f not 'his real name, . but an alias, 1 adopted after his escape from an exile , village in , Siberia, took ' me to his ' private living-room and office, which f was formerly the study of .the Grand 1 Duko Nicholas. All of the furniture ex- ' cept a beautifully inlaid desk and two ' or three carved chairs had been moved ' to the top' of the house, where it ! was stored in f a'eant rooms, Zurin ex- ' plaining that Soviet simplicity' had no 1 patience . irith ' the trappings of royalty. ' Zurin's army, cot-bed stood on the other 1 side of the room. It was conspicuous by' ' tho absence of either eheets or counterpane, ■ .-'':■ .'■" ■•'.■. ■ ■ 'Judge an Ex-Paperhanger. The correspondent asked Zurin where, ■he had learned to speAk English, and discovered that tho astounding president of the Revolutionary Tribunal had spent . five of his thirty years as a paperhanser in New. York City. His 'views on America were father more, complimentary than those , attributed to' Trotsky, who. also spent a part of his So'cialist apprenticev l ship in this'county. ■ : . Zurin summed iip present-day Soviet ideas on courts of justice and law in the - following ' In tho olden davs, .when we had formal -courts of justice, with black-gowned lawyers, justice was all one-sided. Then a skilful lawyer could make black seem white, and turn -.wood.,into gold. They could..dig anything out of law books. The .rich and' the especially, favoured from, .the point.of. view.of -existing , .social conditions were always right in the eyes . '.of ;.the.' court. .If, we, followed these old precedents there would be nothing ■ new, arid to have new laws which assure;justice .to all. is one of the main desires in the minds of those isUDporting a revolution;'ary. culture. Tp-day our. system is nothing more than the combined conscientiousness: of seven men. If we. think, a jnah .'guilty of crtme against thp people as a whole,-wo punish him.. If b» is innocent, he is released. In time there ;will. be biiilt up, a new code of laws covering property rights as well as'an extensive penal code. We have a commission of Socialist laifrers at work'on this'now. ■'■.■,!'"

Permanent link to this item
Hononga pūmau ki tēnei tūemi

https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/DOM19190109.2.29

Bibliographic details
Ngā taipitopito pukapuka

Dominion, Volume 12, Issue 89, 9 January 1919, Page 5

Word count
Tapeke kupu
1,770

JUSTICE IN BOLSHEVIK Dominion, Volume 12, Issue 89, 9 January 1919, Page 5

JUSTICE IN BOLSHEVIK Dominion, Volume 12, Issue 89, 9 January 1919, Page 5

Help

Log in or create a Papers Past website account

Use your Papers Past website account to correct newspaper text.

By creating and using this account you agree to our terms of use.

Log in with RealMe®

If you’ve used a RealMe login somewhere else, you can use it here too. If you don’t already have a username and password, just click Log in and you can choose to create one.


Log in again to continue your work

Your session has expired.

Log in again with RealMe®


Alert