COURT OF APPEAL

Dominion, Volume 7, Issue 2196, 8 July 1914, Page 19

COURT OF APPEAL

LAND AGFM'S COMMISSION AN APPEAL DISMISSED I'ih'oi Scciioi: 1j of I,and Agvuts j Aα li-tJ, tho appointment or oiiij.igi"l iiK'iit <.i , UnJ in connection wi'li Mj(> sili ci yroptrlj i riqinrwi to bo mitfn mw. riti.i A pcuit, is to 'Uic-tlii-r tin, appoiiilikiit or ! must be signal pci»o'i.,ll/ b\ tne pcsoi I t<) bo mailed nitli cominis'ion, ius I mud \PM l) rdii\ iltciiiaon in Mio Court' «l \l)|'jl, »j'ii iho Uuicli n-3 ovv. i-j I , "-' 1 , b J .\lr Justito i! imistoj,!, iu I I" 'karris, ii- Ju'tito Cooiiei, and .Mr Juttico Sfinßc lie pinies to the ction Ixjfoit tho Court cro Joeift .Inmcd lliMs. Kcttlor, of I'alnoiSto.l North, ppppiJnpt, and ildttiicn A-litoii, laid ai,o'it, of \\aui-inui, rcs(>oiu'ti>t Mr U H Coonor, of Palmcthton Aprtli, aproi'cd tor tho ippcilant ( lills), wulo .Mr V 3 Jnidv,cll, of niuig.in\i. appeared lor tho rospond-<-nt ' \slitcn) 'n tuo ori(;i"a! a tion u v-ho = iiprcmo f'liirt. \\ niter Matthuv AJiton {n snoudent) procowlod ajawt Jo*w J"niO6 Hillb <inptllaut> to recover tho euii. of LI 55 !()<■ 3d ns a rom iission an tho si'o o' llil.s'e frrm (218-3 ncroa) to oiil D .M I'lc'v-ird, at tho prico of £oJG2 10i l>l tho altAruati o Ashton chi.uc<l tho 6amo e nn 'or i ork, jouinos, nml attordai ces ncrlormcd ai tli3 rcqufit of Hi 1 - Iht dofciro to tho claim \ is a d^nia , of linbilit; Hills siid lint ir .t woro pn.od tint /shton c t-r < (Ir"to I tho sMo of tho nrc-pc-t thru (Jio cicaiTomcnt of \ c 'utoii is Tgont in r spoct of tho sale nn , ; not in M-itiiic 'Iμ! O(' h, lUh, nid tha ntiT rolmd on tin of Wetior 'S of the L.mJ ARPiif; \ct, 1912 a>: a h-r to tho '(i on Jlilk fuither -ik , tli th" propom, winch hid bcfii eold, "ts iiOMoush t'io prcpert\ of ni" Donald M'lrfin Uu,>ci r r.nd tint Ash ton ljilurcl Jim (Hilis) to tnnsier <-cr tin. l*n<] to Coui or n oxtlnnpo for Coupcr's proporl\ on tho disiiiict pro-nii-.o and tlirt Ashtoii would -fior'vn'tl find a nurchistr abio mid nillinp; to vqmo tho latter pro pom Aiihuiit nn, chirco to l> i-M of (.omniis ion or Ilil's couptflrchii.icJ for £00, which lio rl le;;ed V-l,tori hid r'OPi'od from Pi<A oil i,i tiu-t ior hm. (ihlhO 'Mm cftsn ias piCiiousiy hoirc , b n foro His Iloroiir thp Chiof Jistico (Sir, Pobcit Slont) in ii Sop | _t"tiltr IGIJ nid ii imnit, judznrnt' ids Honour spiil ' Vsm mniK tint tho | nl inlilr (A h ( on) c-nnol cue fcccii.se ! of uii> fml'i.o of tho on rin n l lulnonU J to LompK Mth tlm D-o\isions of Sμ-' tion 13 of tho Iml \t,cnt> \ct 1912, on ncoiinl of not hoi signed h\ tho defend Liit (Hills; perv, ,'h, I im of ojiiiiion Jnt ilifr def-Mid-int i is poi-ioi ■\\U mtliorlscd tho nliintiT (Vshton) to aC(<pt *iio offer .i\ Vγ Pick ml, mid has thu- it ihrribcd him >o ict ii>, hii ijTcnt, ind this brins*. tno FiitlioriM \ lthin t!o words of the si iwte. I aiii tlkreforo '-f opin- I ior. thiu the piiintif (Vshton) can kiio I mill tint lie ■■( cntitlofi to icciior nr | lOiiiniKsio i As to Tno coi'nterchini tins ■ e"cs nr h tnili Dtduct | iris iinount of tm cointorcl im I chill t'n-Toforp fun judcii" , ! t for £05 l(s .3d i\nli -osts "(cordn c; lo scilo, £3 Is fnr films defen-o to rountc-i-him, £2 2? fir Vco\er\, vitntsos o\) onse<i, ind ilr'in foments ' Trom ♦Im (\vmnii the <Wm unt Htilh) -p pohtl nn -"lie. proi nd thiit ,t was crron<y)iis in hv. co'nfi"l fnr tlo anpel'tint je.ito'di\ hftornoin the Court did not cill on respondent's counsti. Tio nn? .nviimou«i\ dismissed with costs on tho ioftost rcalo as froir t. dis tance FIXTURES ARRANCED. WTiPii iho JuJccF took their eeats or xlio Court of Vppcal Bench vcslcrmornuif;, fiiturcs i,oro madf>. ns fellow — Tuesday, Jvly 11 —Justin SlacCar'h? v WiJiinm Madt'cn, san-.o v Edward Vnrtliinetoi; sure v. Alesaiide'V'Don.iid; urn" v. Hiarles Hcwcll, ".isc s oi. froii the Magistrate's Court (liefcro a full Bench of'iho Supromo Co.irt). Juh IG— llio P.idd Mil'--hie Macline Compam v. the Simplex Milking Machine Company, motion for liidcpient Mondi>\. .Tilv 20— Ilirriq v. IIi;t----ton, a iirensmi; appeal (bofo'o a fall lioncli of tho Supreme Chnrt).