ROWING.

Dominion, Volume 5, Issue 1455, 1 June 1912, Page 12

ROWING.

jlir "MWi':r.:!:r."].

RULING AND A REQUEST,. (■■)l v WM.|ij.m|., Ml :(i(l}C:lf|l!il.ill. ' ihity J!!.V'-\Viif|-<!'vi f.Miiniijiiwibliii).: ArhSt v.. i'lhiiy. l-|i/! 'J'friiiim'j, ,' Cbritro.vo.rsy on- the Ihtcr-'VkVliy Race; ; fries l-liiit l.'irvd r-oi.io t<> hfind of. ■- -I'M ■s.iiiiv CM a cr>iiiniV.iTy: .Jnl* ■■J^-t'ii J'.; , ?* 1 "" ■'" *"W'-<>f IJ"! Mii'i-iiiß ■l»fi|ief"H owi; ■ tiic r.i:w.nt fii!.j:r-"V.iu>j , !-y IjonX five*. II; . \\/i! U; .iiciiLKiiJlit'iJCil (Ji;i{ <ii< -fliff-'firU. at,lc)n,ii(; Ui.row .llfn- iiihJ .l;iii:li wmjs Kjyiijnp- . c<l. TfU; tJ{i!ii.lj.i:.i(lL'u- 'cvw \ifii : juiilrti 'Jiri,£; fiiid ttel'fiwl -Coljiiital tijnt blmrtly afUiviViit w-illi tlif.■. of >or.n.«- wilooknw (Mjijilicil. tlmir yvs®, anil Toiresl .'oyeii "tliiicjimf*. i-'lie iiijii/iro, lisuvew-i;, (]»claf«l' :, -tlie. : .riicfi vdirt, (he j:d>«iii fljiljlisliccl 'at iiio : Ihjrfc Jitfi.ig bM<aiiso the Oxionftipvi^hm!--e«i|J,riSi;y 10 i'ulp, pcejw'j^oxtraiicamfiis-; . -swUmta m emptying :tlipi?'lj9at. ; 'aii(l. >«■:; oi.iii)ai. : k!iij, . ' .■..■■■■■., '■ yt )vi!ft()h thffi jjilogej; T-PfmßMliajt- arjrii-- ■ monli !ins ai-isbn,. but ,-,i, ;iiW litiyMojiincnt oii Uie-■■futrt of-tlfc iimiijre .piiU-t"lie-"affair . in quite u (iilierait ].iifhti.-'!l.!orTOver; :il: a jirecpilpjit .that may bo -.of. ■ : flsi> OH si iiVi'liir oticaei'oiis ih ; fu tsire^-iiivfact} . in pit -t'ijsps «f hvo-.iioat raws of tlm. coiffljjjilifijf craws, is .[ilaccit 'liqrs-'cie coiribiit through aii luciivpidiililc ;mUlipp ; > . MorpoVeri it is svqrtliy .of. ifofc fi-ouf' the: fact .fhnt it .is baftil ■ifairly'-.iiiiil-.-s.qiiarelj"' upon, (ionim'onvs'cnsd anil'.«iuiiy,'" '■ "■.';'' Ca.mbriidge-.Gxanian Statement,. '■ '■:■■'.;■ Th.d de.yelopnimt referred , .'to , is -,"i.state-' ■meiit which th.d limp'ire,' Mr- .H Tj.. pit-? man,, .hivs sent .to ihS'.p'rcWs' tp-scttlfi tlio wintrdvej'sy, of'whicl^ruyE;--- , ■■• ■'~ "As a, gooci dea.i .of-(iiscuisipn. liiis"' ■ . .arisen us to thc.:ia.cts of ' liij ruling, jtwayolisßf interest ami;, i . ; s2vj! iifiKiiiVilprstUiiuiiig;/if :i make" ''i' ■' Ktfttcrriejit rlfiiling, sntlv tiiein ; .>' ,; l3olK r ', '■ crews kartell :ih yery rou!;li%ateri ami : ; ■liy the. fime they ■Ji'aiil. :rd\vc(l ; . few fitrdlies Imil s.HiiJpocl- "-ii 'Targq , '- , .aiiioiint of Kiitcf. . -CaitibritlecS ; jiisji.nsfoi'c; Hajrort's : Ayiim:i;;V : ;pxfpf{l ; '■• .did thp' stxmfi '.•. feoti Oxford, havij'igr enVjjtied 'Xfxii '■ "■. iKiafv thesi, stai:tc,(V oil. 1 ' to'row-' '.to"-the.- C! ■fiiii'sjh I cpiiißl'er'.tKat-'.a , . wjiich is jipt exactly d.ejilt rules g.f ra.ciug, .1. :iiiay ?.1y atVoncu ' . 'that, even ; :if .Oxforu re>c;ive([.exhs ; ne : - '• oils flssista.nce,. .tliis' (jiiestioii :<lid :iioi>., -j eitfer liiv Ji'ea''d,. aiid iih'y decision,'jvas- ; ; ftet festd o:i). }I\\]g :Xl\t.;' :";l -of; ; i Qjij'mon that.. I .-had- ■full."power ip-i.-ict.'' Mndsr Ru.tp.-;XVir; % (|dwii 'the l.iSw. t.luif :Uiidpr : j. t-taiices is a,s;rew : jvi!6,:is:. : swumi!sd,>ii>i:s ■titled re-enter it'g ibqatV ljut iii; ithis'■■;; cas6 Ijo'tji :crews had:ijieoii. wat'erUciggkl',,.:''. ■frtni the start, ami hail ''i ■na-'fii'iijt q{ :tlio'i ; racey,. could jijoifc ;be: dec'.ideil by .waitiiig" vtb/i sejj whiclv crew .coiilH :scrarable::)iack;S into tiiio- ■bp.rit.amli'get to; tji'o:.,"winniiij-; ■* : .post, fifefc "I..'dci :; not '.th , iiik?f;shouldV!' : ha'ye..ijeen right.'ijif ■ , a , irowij.ig , '.dxfprd^to i !v"i' complete tlie. cpurSf. an'tf..il .-liadCiio'iK' .a!!tflTnat:!ye' I]ufc'to;!rtronce':inf6rm;tlieiiir;vvl a'.s'.l rti'd-ji'f'■'Chisw v icXr' : .th.i't , :l'j«lcil;i i ts?; ''race..' '(Signtd) ilVed;.:ili,:l!ity:':;; .yinii." ' .'.' ■' "' ' ' " i; '' ; 'Xjf ■Eo.r !f!i.o .Information, jgf , ■rea'ders'.of.'.^iris 5 , column, 'tfje j.ules. i-efer : reil.'.(:p'i ,are; the ■ laws ;, j)f :IJ'oat 'raci.hg.. 'J'h'o. 't\i;6": , ref«rre'dj. : .to)' , .par: ticn.iaiil.v. xuii:r-"' ■"' , : . 'A ■ .Tvof. vXt'V.; ' s A'ny : , cbmpJß.titnr , :-.;-.rccemng '.Eivy., qualified at, the , disci'etibii.of.',th'e"jnnpire.'v. ■; Noi. XA'tl fell ; th.6 ,, r(uthf>rity;ioj ; :whic]i ! ,J[r. ..Pi.tina.h- aeted-rr}i6t;';ns that, tsf: JS'q. 14; ajjoyej::'. risdi c tioij' :bf the: ,tfmmrp. :<|itenn.s ,ovor a'.: raccv'/ti-fid ■■■ijU- iiirtttor's" co.iiupct«d. ,'witji; : ijt^froin.yho . .(■•iii'e. .the rape . .to'.^start.;uiiliij its. .fM.mina.tjgu-. :and : liis' ■(Icc.jsibif'.in ."'all', cas.us sli.'dl':M.filial:ihn'iV-'ii'itliqut'.'aiiyncal;"' Is a.;RenriatiehtrCo.UfS6.-.bcsirabicj f. ; '. Dui ; i'ng:..-.the \reok- .tlie'"'foHowinp:. l'pttor iJ^diivrh.'wcU'-fciib^'-Towjrigi.entSiusiasf'-S-nsj ■received at .iliis 'It.-.isv selfrCsplßrisif tokp, (iiiil "J[erci!i : y"'!loi)ps, ; tliat;;Jlr;: ! "braitlt. lvjll- tep his-V«..yf tojvar<ls",reply.iri|;',; asilio opinion of one ■-.of ■)he- roinngicphditioiis-ipf^tlioiDnthinion would lie dtfb'idfijll.v' .ihfer'eM.ins;; ,, ..to".' ! bo!it-, jiiijj liiflh .fepho'riilly'"cwii-:if A -.dp' lVpt prove , ' ■cbnyihciiig'.Jtp:,;iiiy;.occri,csi■pwiiifpiif. .. : . -. "■■" ..' : "'::&' :'£f-};s , .Alfo , "Mprcpry , ' , -^oijld i : .i>f aiiy , ,plhe.r..:of .o.iif.boaU'nfr■■cnHiusiiistsVqif 'itjiis i>pi;nk. .Ho ■]oiov.s , 'fosiij , -'o£;OHVf?piofq'n' : fi'tendis foci strqiisly-.pii Wit* ; mat! en ..Hefei -folldivs the; ilctfe'r ■. . ; ; ; " ~;^ ■'■?f. : ZL.' !-1i 1 ' .:2SH^:stny','-i.nJ2 , .;,j i)eiir 'the.SlflK'.Boafiii?' Gilujfe pjttieiitatioh Ijriiitii, jiiv propasini; , ;tlfb' (oast-of : ;?:the ~s.'£'AJ*4'* StrfliiKl^.;adv.ocate , d-:;Hiat<'tHero :s ; lipjijd bS a. .'iierniimont' , . .'.i'championshiiv ■.cp.teei and .-Jlpt ..Bavfieldi iii 'ircplyin'R;-: -efaied , ' tlia.t the::. AyelJinst6i ,, ?A«sbciatj|oiii : al?<J : fevquro(l t'.ltis-lftPaV.'," ■ : ,-' '■, '.:■.:■ '■' "■' •■: Mr. Galbrriith , i.nscd- tor" Insi-.arpumcht; tho -fifcp (hat : riiial ropdrfs : ina'lcps mpiition" . : .t.lia'| ' ■■•t;h«; ' ■cliainpiqiislifj) : ineet'iiiß.' 'at ,Ayaii'K'amiiUwa's.' .pfloriy .siippMtflif.- -Vi'hH: '.ihi's: isliguJduW-'a;.-■rea'sphj-for a.:i)prnia.neiit ..course..oiipvifails: ■To liiuioistaiuK' If ■popd- ; ?ntn'cs\c.anHpfc-:hq- = .-iobtiiiuo(l"-for, u i-cVfiti.it:'-.at , AVaiignmii',: ivh.erp at le.-fst. :pn> eii.ii ■■'nlwfa.vs- :bij j'^'wei!', '■off,' Wl'li' s : h.fli'.id. ihey : l> 'plitiiiined: ' ni.or.e- . r.p'ii.iii.ly' elsb'ttiliorcj" pvoii' dj.i 'i; ■-.'perma'njij.t.V .cbi!i;sf-'? 'And agAiiii t ho. ,iici> ■ ■ uiii.iie.iit cqiii'fo , '.were , at' Wangiii'iujj lio.w; .tlioly-? ' ■ . '■''." .';. :'.' ■;. : The writer poiisiclora '.thai;: '.bpjfSrp . flio flelosates v.p'te on ■siich (n'u- ; 'i!iippr.laiVt:()iie?-; fib.iv '(.hoy : s.hpjild- qljtain.' tlio::[fooliii'tr.-; \of: .-I'lfeii' i:ai;ig.iis -pljiljs-, ;is li.b' !hin!cs':'f-troiisl.y. ■f.liat luan.y -nipn.ifierii , - -jvljtf :liayp .ha.d f -:tho: : .exjier'i-o'n'cp 'iii aftoii'di'nj 'and , . lir'bnrpn;.-^-,; .giilUi co'iivin.ilteps: wpuld..stfqiiftiy:;o!jipct:'(p., ■a■ 'permanent .course , ,. The ■fiiie>itio , iV : .6fj'-;fi;| naiico. is, j.n i.tspif,- iSiiflie.icnfc .(b.. ; coii.deihiU :i'K Jt, .ciihiiOt : .]j.c< 'exiiecfar ; HUU : 'aiiVi ; onb; 'li.l'aco , '-.".'libiiliU eye-ry , . ycari -rnftft •'Aiifiei.ra't;*-r-fjihds/'to-'l'.iui- a .phaiiipipuiihip.;m«;!in?,'. ;and. this iasspeiatipu- .-lias, .iiof ' : finvds .16- ' . . :...''''■.'.,":'■'V: . A'no.thPr .argument hc.ainst Die; , ' , is- jlinf.no. "iown 'should- -liaytf U. inpijojjy.v,. i-a'ii'iV'-U , is, q.nly >rriiinU .tlip V: iiicofc--Unit i.ha.t' jiitprosi; iri..v.ro«:|i|E..c'a)i"-.-.b'e.. eiiT. .'llnispd' , iii .some, of -tlio. ceiilTeS. ■ ..- .-'■' ' i'ea'ij'' Jf-s. GiJlbrn'.itl.i ihpii.tion- wiiiy ..jilncef-f .v-'herb , -ouo pai) iß.tiaVniitcp- ,((i. hplcl'.a:.inec(:=; 'iris''.in plvnmpiniisiiii) ;watf ; r.? . Tor.- ~. ffei'ce, iii 'Welliiistpii :i.t. Kiiiiiipf.-'liej.'docicip* eiV -ujVJril the: diiy : nf ':Q\k rcdsltiV:' Vvvliiclv; I !fl ™* p.'i,. lEiSlpji-Jiiul Jvorsylli .iro-: ffaffas: have boi'iv ■l)ps.f|)oiip'd- : ...:'MTanTinu j i aiid Slprcoi- )iayb! to.p m'iieh. w'licmiii wiis feied. fpjiml '..; T. linVf o'ftpiv. 'lipari! 1 ths>.'.li.iaHTp'.'dise.uss-:. ■Ed,. bli.t ini.vp rie.vcr hfpA; H: "^'ii^ljO's o '' l,l^' ■jii'Pf.vfinipn'f "iii -favour -of; ; jj:, '.Fcvlia'p'sV..;MrV■G'allVrart!) ->v.nulcl' fi.6--? h o .cppdl ii>? ; to;:,pnli(;ht-; oii "the:, arid: Jhrrowinr'liublie-.onj :t!iK la -fli'tiiii, fp) : y .iiiinprtaht .miittor'..:'.:." , ,! "A\:i(k- -lYuaii'd 'to' JFr; GiiibrnUhls ; iivt ni.iirks aS. '.t'6'' .aH'€ii:iriß-'.;t)i«- definition^nf '.air .oiiiatoiii! nVeiitioned. at. the "fa'mevjivep.tinjt.'Hio'wi'ifeii '.fti'l apppi'd-kitlv;liimi'nnd; iliiilks- h 'yhxy liirpe ■■i)erppn!nee.; / of : :rowiiipr. ■inciv iilsp favoiir t!io 'alteration;;;:' i^.'^-i-.