COURT O APPEL

Dominion, Volume 3, Issue 632, 8 October 1909, Page 11

COURT O APPEL

■ Y) r-S EfiVANT? S\C AS E r ;' ; ;; ":■".,_ :\' S";pmETIIE?ITAL !JUSTICE. "■'■ ■ ;'S^§(^? : '-ELSE WHEUE.;'. Justices vAVillinffls •: (Acting-Chief '. Jus. .S;W%i»-.V.Konnistpn,V']3dffards ( and: Chapman ;ir tioijft' r :'ofi /Appeal ; .cosp'». ' : Arthur Broad :^';£^ft6ldsy^a/"GiyilVSoTyan!^^V^.^^ s !'l Attorney: John? Augustus' Hnttoii, 'and AVal V':-^ •a^.;Mr'.'.-H : . H,* ..Ostlei •2'Sj^^V^^^^ r !" Respondents; ; vC- ■•■■-.'■ '■■I'iS— ; ■ s :'boford-.:his v'llbflbur'.Mr./Justicbv.Oooper when:the y case i; : : {#?i&/,befqr£i : that; appbllaat; ; a. Civil -""\pOf;Vanfc?;of ;25 "years'"standing, had been'susin Juilc ,;: jastiichnrges ;bf .misconduct being. made ■ againsl iwhtmU >He;.denied- the :truth' of ; tho charges .^:Ma}?Mess^s^'■:Hilto:';ond'■^Boffl<^ 'jyfvanty wero under/Section l "lß 'bi to .inquire iiitc ?";tne.:allegationa,- -awli a»er; fully hearing' the • Wf-'.'-fo ; report'their ..opinion to tho" Governor ;/, subject;to epileptic,,fiU :.<M^ovM to 'attend >the -inquiry,' and engagec' , ■*Mi*)m.l*M presented : : BowTa *u&'W£ ; 'explaining" appei; ■■A$Mi R ?? Mcc; I'.. <W"> solicitor'. was '.'; excluded, ; i,^' :.ovidouce. bein-i ./.WUed-'n/appellantV defence"..''■ :.'•'.'- •'■• ■-"'■" .- : i' ourt >?? Appeal}was'tliai aclo I?PP icat 'M ; 'to tho - Su. "IE^ 1 '■ a ,' wr * "(/Prohibition :i o ' re. ;with :thei. alternative.'for a writ oi the repoWV2 ■;^f : W,/T9 ll J.:;becauso/appollant 'had beer IfSE ",?*• V nh T d l' his 'Honour;-Jlr. Justice '• Governor had 1 "sss*s■& the officer by '«* i|??rf' of the - board. was not a ••;■•?s#*&*.•nad.vno-control .'ove'rvthe'.board '^ '/Sffed/tO:ineotf;tUe appellant. Wtos oni? .::{|p'p.!fho : V $&'■' co »)<taot? layevhr.d a Rood "deaßf' t hi c ?"'«v before the ■'flßfeste Governor^ ..CpMcil,,Pr-toiasfctthat-.the'. matter should L >mQ&?% Ci T- n ' ; '/ ,nt * ; to i' tho ' Caurt. ;S ee" ; lt*v-\ h V'' ° ' ;Clalnle(1 ins a egal right If :;»:?Pt- <""npH?d-withrappellant had atigh f m*k. .jO; contract,!: and 'he -," ?IH-!*■•;*?• damages,: unless the Crown could , Properly: dismissed, :ho.: was Entitled" either to to.danl'aKes:'..'' Before" certiorari could :}?#- : f d . e '«mina ion."and;that dotermHa-i-W^V^k^-^'WOSO "liability ? o""S "r s& : !i; %° .-•.PPJniqn.vof -the'.board gave-thS lS , #? ( ' l ™.™a i »' bound -tb tak6™t. ■ bWKi f'-I^.^PW on^n itscK did :nbt-: affect 'i a P^nt's: ; ppsihou 6r':rights;. ''",'. :CntiL:th« ; .board lias ~raa;de, this report. Jio has the/right-to •remain '>^ , ?-.'i a i , ?M^l>*Mft ■"" i£s^':^?«/ Chapman^ '■;^K^ ! '^??' ! i%W ,l !l* i; ■is ;: only' a 'part S S . p l t s -- on; • h '^P,? s vbetbrei the' ! mquiry; ; ; ,^ ;-w , '' '■■■; ;:--/"/'/'/"" ■^ii^^ r ?^J a^"a feS;owse;-: : under ,no: alteration -in "hk .i#ft .^pinion' ;of; thV. Mr! he f?«pted.V',K /Was ;eo mi -the-Eieoutiye. Cbnncil -to ' say: : JV,?.i?* nt -inrthervinformatloni !and we a? 11 Kfifi!'f r ? l ?s ß^ e f o this nian. "■I??' ttta'/Jt'.would.ppen-.the .whole' thing<to iiffl;^ r 't?! d:^^i f ; ' a PP' e " a^'na a. ; a^ .6Wte;of,.his.bealth : at the'time-bfythp inquiry; opportunity !to :^u''^ S -'^!* i:^^d^>?he ' -prbperV/course send ,^Mh'M^?:--'^}!i '.would.-.have:been 'done. •.. •SX! , .V?» s h<!«;.'Ed!ra'rdsi.fThat^/may, be.;/> ii^-tL My^s: - il ,'. a ! n - in :'' a . P°sition- to say: : 6P had not powerVto do' that.witha:consent; ; have'said: v ;l'.jbm;notVgp)ng. td: ; atten'a'now.V:-y-i:'•'■■■ ■■*&#&£ - : ; > vwhibbn-equires iMim JH d SO shall.put':on-a;.blact,cap; i s . as ' "jf£ )r is? a . l ??> n y^' n g' :l;know-e«eptin e '-the Sif"^^-^^' u<£rw ;days.' afterwards. ..r:.?, e iff h . o !?,q;eatioi»' for this board'-was:'. "Guilty Pit found i .', , auilty;','.';, then epmM:/the. sentence'.' -r^yy-.'!■■:,' -2 : -^J'S J!«t'ce;;ChapihanKCould v the' Goneral.shave.taken^proceedings"' : 'to-iuve- the «Mf tefrtasWdron.;. ','for.-. .'■•;:■•..'',;■.■;'■ . ™r.S e ? e *wy^*Mause ) '':if..ther6 hasbeen-no i-e^ now^i''^^^-^^ 1 itart ' de ttib|d;!*?fe^ i^ a 'v' : 'W^:^P ro Ps rI y : 'ofirolli^Ml« C > : °^P^ D: '^ b^ues Sfe a *fefe; a n answer^.;. Cbuld the/ Attor. SM9 e , r . al 'i'. ha ve 'commenced -! n regular : suit 8 4t,"t0: obtain ?-sf'i?, 0 ' now.askibg for?'.';'>.-: : ;l >snbmit:;ha;ibultr nbfc this: i» a..imere;rdelegation.'-'.•-•: •'/■',."/.•-..■■..-. ;.3ustice.:Chapmnnft :;NoV-tho-Attbrney, S° .W''P r i o, =? ed nponithe ground that' the IfMt-has..m.sbehavod-;itself-'*l-'"do not■ s.pv iS : .vif a ' ; i , )? Dien - t^ hat ' f has "Ipno.so-wilfillJ,' two;persohs,'-.act-mm-fi ;jud,cial Rapacity, 'on'; the -ground -. that 'Wfc : We;.-»oN9Hpwed: the. statute,.and:dono JM("ot/,injurioiiS; tp:a; subjeit,':and implicated ffe?P7 e - r nof: ; i.ii : .,a' possible liabilitv..; Could »?S.S?« /-Attoi-ney-.Geheral,-y'iindor.' these :-cir??S?t a ????V- a ?;ft.;;m(itter:fdf public, right, pro-' Medito'getiridjpf-that/repbr'tp.o/" .: r -;•■ .Vi^vMy?rßl/It"is:dbiibtfnt ;-:tho-Executive'is '.;■■'."':■;! "''■■ that the:report had fe/'Sr A 0 '.Governor -.through 'the. -Minis: *!&"?- ■' : i?Wt3M*it -as; the f .it,wos hot ; yet -in the bands would 1 be easfefor, a;meeting-torbe called'any' time.-at *mch:.it.could .be:handed' over by ;the;MinisSMiJl'iJristice'■ EdwardsrTliat :wouidrbe'a tihMly'.'improper-.proceeding,.'would it -not?. /:ifr^./ ; Myers;: -'The"Courts would '■iot .make effect;bf;.wbich'--wonld be Mprall/v-to '.fie -the -hands'of : the .Execntivo Co;meil,vjfhfln the/Court; had iia'ot jurisdiction *^ ; .SsmpoT- ; it3J^vrit^. : .b>Aperfbrmcd.: .'-T- '■■■; '{■:»r;;;.Tiisti'oe.'%:'aWbn: 'Could "hot the Court haying' it before it? the to'say: I'The. Court has teijnrisdic{ibrf. : .i)ver.i)'i,,ahd'wb ■■ will disouss (J.e';.'rtinh.":tKe 'order ;of:thb.Court would havt nb'ieffectVnt;all. J -/ :'.'.■:.>:■'•■■»'..'.":■■-; yfyi- '-';:. /iWf/;,Ortler. ; replied,'/and : .tho:Court reserved |ts',.uecision;:;;{:Vi». 'v.;..; '.'>>'. Ji~.. -i-.-: -; V--J* ;■ --.: -' r - ■_- -- - ■