LAW REPORTS.

Dominion, Volume 2, Issue 621, 25 September 1909, Page 13

LAW REPORTS.

;y;^£;^ C;iV:^?'An ; >aoK6ri^VM\ ; li?Md: by'.'Mr."Justico'.Chiip- .'■ '■'■■.'"■ . niiiuV in "Chambers yesterday/ in which Christo-, ;i ■ >-:';;<pb?r''John' Lynß,'toacher. at Lower: Hutt; l)is- -•'..■■•;■■■.'■; trict/Hjgh'iScflool, J .B6ußlit:to''obtain l an(interim .V'S:' ■'•injVu'iotionivrestrainisgv.,the' / .Wolliiigton. Educa-;. ..; ■ttion-Board. fronV'f cmoving.hini'.ff omYtlioJschool ,'. 'v'.'vandvstopjiiugi'his'. salary; y,Y ■■:'.';■' 'YYY'Y'VvY; >i:' ; r:V::;''---MK' : i!;-!\v ; /-: : pWiiitiitiVtBhd : Educating v:YYvY;Y, 'Juriliis::statemeat:of,'i.olaiin,'iplaintiff'sot-out .'.'■' Ythat hoviastemployed-a'S; teacher; .in v ;t!io:i.o;wer v- ?:•.'.; ,Hutt 'School;-, '.and,ion: A : ' ; V-'April loJa9J:,.he.;waS''absontrfrom liis'dutiesoiv- ..;;': "rHouf KY'Y-mntisrii,: -'Ho^sent'.the;key's .of- thb school by ;aj. :!:-y\V>^'ro ;':•;;' ■; ■ giving :tho-;fcas6nJrf liis''absen'cb'toYthe' head-. :;;>:■ Ci'oUowihgCriio'rniiig'vlie l f'c'-' .:..;';, ;;. : -BntoejV;J!'Ui^- :^cl«fie'a'V.'»tLl itJie ; ...',t.tt ;.. •■';;iO <inire:3is .to.'h'isYabseucoYoiiitlio previous, day,: YYY ■';..bufc;'p i quite; ;wVv ; i&bettei'i:.iiucl,;-?t;ilib;?were.' absent in Itho"-after-' y ;■: j .'.'noon^ih'e.'headm.asf'er..would 'kiibv.-" Iho- reason'. '.':>:'. : of tl)is r :abseuce:v--Owing .to" . hi*,:ilVrheilth/' lie '.;:'■' --'v. was isbspEt •'-- n'vthe'; afternoon';. .'Tlia't- : ':eveiiiiig, '• .members cf thts'Scliool y,;:'.'YYCommit^ . ■■■-/■ ■: :'-OW;!ng''tb;;his:'"abseneoiSyithout'leave' of'. sufhV .; -.: . cietil..;c.BVse:'.-'';r>By bolter,.^dated'<Ajiril VB, 'the ■;.;: . jßecrctary'df Hthe't'Educnrioh; Boifet: 'purporled ' v:J O^ co bfirm,:;the-sußp>ilsioh.y: .On"April.';]3,' r tlie ■:.■'■■;';*'■ '...School::Cbmmitlee.Tbmt)ved'-thb alleged suspeh- <■': B f at the ;:'r„ -. ::f"Mbl'; for. tlfe ;pu'rposo; of: resuming ■hi.-:'duties, :"',.& .. bu prevented..fromi :doihg'so'>by";ttm:head-' ■'"•*■■*.''■••■ I :. ffl k' , ter,-,' J 'ahd:.'n'' • niehibcrYof •the' 'cb'jimittre.Y'as ■i'■:■■ £:■- if ™l'?ving;teacher/ ! was feachlng^fn. his';p'nee.' : ■■■'".-'. v ';:Ho:;was,therefore unahlo: ; to. resume 'his duties. y'.; ; .a;•lctterv-frbm :, the i :.'-•: I yy; WRW;\°f irthß'vßducationVJ'Bcara, .''directing YY;Y 'oh 'tho" i'fllh. !On .■. , ;:: ' JP 15 [iraf rs; he'resiifried -his'■ (Jtitios]?nrid liiiil,con-! ;; ; ;:,>U':V. n,^ed, ; m.i,the' performanceYoflthcm , ''with6tit' ' "y : Y. - : lit r ther • ..ctirh p 1n i nt\ •or ':ahje'4cb' : from'-'his' v:»-■'•-. da«es^On';the;;evening;of■YAprirab,'plaintiff ■■j- . .-;:• appearedxbefpre-f theYSchbol '■' ComniittepV'ahV' ■:,:,.>■■ -:goye;!|nn^; : ;oxplanation!;':bf 5 .his: .abseii'-e. h, *■*';■' Y-Ue -ii::.tendered,j,:-the -,i evidence";,'of l ' * 'the : .Y ; ;: messenger.:, sent ■■''■:■■ '■■h l e ?d,<naster,-:but' tlib committee 'infused /to'' fs'raf •-)<■!' : ? -', th «-.ovidonce;>,J!i6:cominirteet s a!xo' dcclvted-"to — ■•■-■' '/f?J?<P?r t 'Milars'bf the charge, which theVplnir-. oi-v to '.per mi t li iti i' ■to ;''■■ •' Y^Ci'bsS-Mam'ino•the.-.wituesses'calied.i/rhe-amiiinl, -'■:;; y- : ;V' ,?! ec^bni: ;o£ta;'sch9blA'cbmmitteo ; ; took-v plnt'o' b« ;/.', V:":.'ApnJ-26,aidrtjbe: : new cbnimittee.'did -V; :■; '■■••■vihessa i s.<pOn'-'Ap'r'il\3o,- .'the secretary-of-thb Eiib'-' : : V. >:;i;Y'-,:n?*itp;-rMipii;'Bnd:.on May: 19'andf20, plaihtiil' Y."'i>': , Jl ; ith•"par : ti-■. '■■■ YY ; '-eulara.-bf the'cbafga'againstUiiin! ;Thbse were; Y;-V:, : 'Y to 'hiin. '.OnYJiine.l7, "aYsitb-' '.i.conimitteo "of :sthe''-defcndaAt'.board ! .'n(et"'Soii-.c . ,' vV' -Wembprs bf.tho.'s'ohbol/'cbumiittee, anii'cohfpV^ ■' ';; YveitU ,th"bm : with' .Tespcct;.t6 : Ibe: conduct, of .the :■:;;; Y; plaintiff. stated ■'■ thatY: they - t- '! : '.Y.wquld;takeVno:furthor action.',YOn'Jnhe 29;,t1i0 ! i ■.'.:' ;Y .'.SecretaryYof jihbi-bbardYwroto. 'to.'Vthb YptaiiftiiTY:. : . ~ ; ,i pursuant;' -pur-V.-,?;;;.,pbrtingvto'tbriniiatovhis e'ngageriieiit''as;'£rdni ;Y. Sopteuiberiao."-.llldin.tiff field .'that Ythis'all&oii ' ;Y..; ;toruiiiiatipn : %asYibyalid':ah'd':;ultrav; •fires,' 'be'- " .;-'l .cause■ (I)'^,Th6:,bha"rges;v : .; /.properly'.formufated,v,or 'speciacally.madelYanj ';:'• Y;hoihad';not:beeri<given'an;bpportunity,bfmeVt,;Y;;Y vng.'^thcjmj;i(2),ihe;vhad ; giybn .a-foil .'/ : 'Y. : Y'''oppbHhiutyC'!iff.''tend6^ng r ths);e'Hdance'<pf''liim-' -;.',;:Belf'apd/Wsiffitnfsses''in -his;qwn-defence';..(3) -;.-.,; .he/had-BotJb'oen ;giybtf:.ai'oppbrtumtyYpr.lDar-.i '...'■■''.-■';■'.' -'ingv/thaY. evidence Y nesses-whb''gaye,:'eyjdence dgairist hiiiiji(4) the: 'YY. Yf defendant ,boafd. : had.;'pbt 'dnly.br: properly-co'ii-: Y y Y;Y suf ted ,beforeY:plaintiff's :■:■; : ;:;.;-," missal;;(s);:in-'fhe''.alleged -confpr.ence .of.'.June', :.y.y Y:l7Ythe. ; Committee -wasjjiot^dnly.'consulted ; 'with y ::Y, ; regard-Yfo Vplaintifi'Si'-'dism ■:'■ Y.Y: ') noticeY;in;.iirriiin'g'■ to',th'e',elfoct"that:'snch busi-l ■: ;''.;■:." nß^^wa»:'pipposed;'.'tVY.bei-'tra'nmct6(V'!had' : : not Y,;,.' v 'been-iaddressed ;merabej ,of the''.conf-l '. 'I-'-;.'',.-mi ttofl'.* three :!days; befbreY tl{e' , meeting';';.and ! .'(C), YY ,':.. the com'raittoeYwas;ript'cbnsultbd,-'inasmuch as Y.Y: Y: yy -;yytb : 'fofmi:aii : opinion'|Of. ; gi'ye\adYice..£ ; '.Y:. ; : : ,T'.'"■''•:-. Mr, ;C " ; ,Yi,;.: : .facts should "'■'■.■:-■■■'• Y. Wore!thß.i^iOT>BsS,,ffM'depia^a'apbfc yYY:.;been necessajy>tiapp<a!;'.}», : -Y.'.!.-; ",: ns'-nb'i'chorge'.had hoard:by:';thb -Teacnefs' .Board .of Appeal; :l'lio' '•:.'.•.-:;: idea ithat ; plaintifi'e:;absence : from dnty'Ywaq _ 4 .': YY:,-. ■_: bacaosb'of-'drinking 'habits ihact bean abandbhed; , ' V:,;.:' and l hiß''presenw'iniarhotol'had -liMh, explained byY'the ;fact''that;he .Vwas;jraiting::'to.;seb a ' '•':■: Y Y doctor, ■ 4 '.'YY Y -"';;■'. -;-r.; •■fii"'i-'-; '■■; .;Y;.; ,Y,;.f,-. ;-.-V£ v ''■''.''■■'•". ■-~-X Mri v Brandon -contended: thatl'teachera* who YY//cbisidere'dHhat;;thoy 'had e'eanse i for complaint, '■il'' ! , y upon; the'' action -of an education board had a Y V remedy Yin'-theYßpecially-established; court -'-'of ■0 that: the Y board YinYthis .;;-i'-. y< case/.had : hot-.biceede'diits jurisdiction.jYi .>;'■.';' i; i ; Y^Y : Judjrment; :^'re&w^^

' : ,; nimcd'-Frcderick' Henry . -. .-' '. ■'■ tHati' being 'already' a* married .-man,-'.he. did, ou ; . ■/•' December- >15, v jo ') the<,fprm •. of; mar- : /'/Mage ; 'with:r:ano,thcr' : ;.per6oh,? Mary Jane .Col- , v !;l(ris;.'.;*; Chief-Detective Broljerg. applied; for „a j . next;;.//;, /; Wv.:,'!-/. i - : , ■• Wiliiam''-Henry":EaVards.l*aß'- charged /with '\ > -'aMatdte4-i>hdVl)eatehV::one;»-Alexander- //-■:' Johnston '.Defendant pleaded >--:"-""-'- I -BUiJty:.,vilt''-'»ppear«d- : -.'tlidfc -arose • /•'\--^' : iiiVan' , ;bffice:;oTeri''a , i'di9pufe / 7inV-roforericejfo,. ■' , -an' accbunt;,'.',Deieid'ant' struct :plaiutifl' • when . ; ■:'. ;/,thb 'parties ;were'/in '.tho/office ;and/continued /■v.^-'Hfie'''assanit-iii'- 1 / ': : : fine/ bfy'2o'C ariU''costs//.£U 135.;,-was .imposed; ■'V'■";■.:-JJr. : .Buddie ■'appeared /plaintiff.///;/;;/::: ,;/■ / ■ y ]■■y^}^im^i^^^^:^^r'. •■•' //'./Reserved /w'as/givon/ih/tho/ldng '••;'• // oritstandirig/iCaso/ih/ which ../.Thbrnas/Carswell. ///. td:jproyid6;;for;:the ; /-■ mairiteriahco"of /his/illcEitimatb/child.-.v After ' ■■■■'•■''' '.■'■:■ traversing'-tile'..'evidence "hi•.'sdirie';. length/- his / vLWo'rship-h.old: l ;;that/!dcfehdaht\:must , ; bo ;. ad- , '.'•-: judged/tho'putative/iathcr/6f/thb : 'child',and. ' '.•V-' ■ ordered -him/to 'pay. 6s//per-week towards/the. ■-/ ' maintenance/Of;t\e;.c^ifd:' i Defendant; J was...ako. , s .'ordered ,''.- : appearedi;for.{defendant,/was/granted/leavo' to; / ,app'eal;'fbr.-a-reheaniig'.iii.His>princiiials;6hould so;-tteeide: v : ,Mr;f;Dii';appcarcdsfor.:vCbmplain-. ; /.:/■ ant;///; :j/,: ./ » ? -'U'''*':W ; ;: : "-'^!' , --i? : 'vl: . ! " : -,v:--;':'- .' -Aloiarider/Harley : ..., .TitH being-;theifather';of-an .illegitimato.'chiUK • :'■' / was/di.nnisscd/withbu't ,prejudice,rafter...hear-: ■:^^.--«liig*evidoncb--' , it.''sama>lengtli^, , -Mr>lColly , -'ojH' ."'.'■ ipeared /bi>,complainant',aud'Mr/.P/W.:Jackr /" bod/.for, /defendaut;//>s/.;.;>., i/.\ ././/•/ : /'/. /^/////'%',-i,/.^^ //-/Georgei-Williains^'ploadcd^not a' ;:■-'.'• /charge,' of driving/a,'v'ehiclo/wiihout > a/light. ■'::■"in "• Adelaide' -Eoad'..after/ buniet.,; .'Def ondant :•; informed' thb l conrt.')tlfat '.ha, /was:'at ;hpme.by. ./-\.;?;:V%6 , cl6cK''oa..;ftß.'''day/f.in'/'qnesHbnj/-and .his /Worship ./dismissed /the' -information.-'.' -' - / •;''.: '}- Apn a/charge! of /driving-a >mqtor /car,round •■-■. a corner l at other pace,.Charles ■';-. ''■Monte Mb'titef.ore/was;fined./403/:.arid costs.3ls.-. ';',»'./:■'■■ Defendant/Was,; represented-, by., Mr.'Wilfbrd// ''..,:■ .'i-jpot'-:riding a:bicycle, on'.a\..footpath/ : at 'Ka- ■."-. -'■';; rorjV; Henry /Henderson./was/, .fined.;/ss. • and '.'■; ■; /costs.7s./,:•./■//'.;/./:':•;/';.';',//';//. /l;;//;/. '.Mbntey'^^William .A'dama'was..fined 59.',. arid ■•■.:-; costs ~7s.|'.for/aUowiDg ;twoi horses'.;t6" : . be ■■ at /:.v'larao;;in/'WillisVSrjeet../ ; i;.'^"cv: , /,/v/; ~■ ''.: /■Foi-:,attcinpting/toibdaril.:a 'trariicar Trhil'si '.../,'it.'jvaj/.-in'/motion,-; Colin.-Campbell/was', co'n- . -victeil,'".and'.ordered-' to/pay;,costs,, 18s/,'•.'■'.. .;:,-. '.-.. -/, ■ i ; A , iiiio of ;-10s.,'i and • costs,'.-7s;,:was' imposed ~..'.- .oh:, IViUiam'vAntrobns -;for'. allowing., stock to .-■•■ wander..ZJbhn.-..L&nb.'and,'Mr.ry, ieeloy,' simi- ■• .:'■' larly.' chargccl,'..were:.cabh.'fined ss.^and -costs, ';./■'■.:■):■'; ; A order',, months' // .1 currency."was.'issued, against'-Dennis :Yoro./.V : \A -fiiic ;of:• 4fls.,:iandHcpsts,' : ,93., '.was -entered .'.'against',-.'V7illiam..;Leir]S'."Allen/-'..for;: entering :,; /whilst-, a: iprohibi- ■!;■ ':■"..'' tioii.-'order J . against ,;hiin force;.; .V;. ; ... ,: . ■ '■; / yyy =-y : : ; f -'•iv',-'.'-'.-"A^finb^of : 2(ls;,/arid';,cbW/jei/125./'wM' eri- .-.: : teretl agaiiist'Aridro.wß.and Marithell, 'Ltd:;'for : ethploying ari'iinliconsed. wirbman'.to;cany but ■■'■ '; certain/electrio'work."-Sr"" ; /-/;■/-.; v'.::.,:-:-,y- ---,'/. • Antonio;-Berriasconi/pleaded'^guilty''.'.to 1 -/a ■'.•- : Krbacli of-the IhdusWal.-CoriciliatiOn," andArbitration.Act,, in.i.that-hei failed'to'. kebp/:a v wages -and b00k..;. A-fino: of. 205./: and '■' /'-".-costs"7s.,;w.as.,- entered.//v/ : ;',//://,.-£;.,-./.: