MAGISTRATE'S COURT.

Dominion, Volume 2, Issue 442, 26 February 1909, Page 11

MAGISTRATE'S COURT.

(Before Ut.'V. G. Eiddell, S.MO

ALLEGED WIPE DESERTION.

|-?lfAimidaie:ap;mW^^^:^:Cas-;«^»ol>rietyt-waß;'conTiotedsand,«ned:iUs.,,.in,a').. ;5vJ- foelt ;^p^p.nn^^;:K^vv:^^::- V:.. olaimed;.t6;reooyer frpm : defendant^e ; ft,:S: y >euii:of 12a. gdvjhe.action-being spute "v:' lMtwe6a^αaαandlord^and,;tenaftt t a 6 ;;&:-rf-the'-two-shouldpay , formal eratlone-an4;re|; Entirely;, new the. hndlod; .■ '<;;« was ! lesporieible^fA^thev.tenant ■ did not .cauy : tKe ;-r'eaii4iJbnii, ; of .•( the Com-, e^the^an|l6rd;S*f(flave ; ;the i j ■^-: J ■■:;: : * «forKa\hott-3p^;tte.;groundAvtta^plau^ >^K^e:.leasevwasi4riginal,ifrom.:-one: Payne ■ : •■ •' i A.proauptiony -4i|tlej:inV.plain-. £ ::^;i:tiff's : name: •^r.- : ■;yViv : ';tiatidefendSnfc'i.waß. ; ': liable 1 ; tb>'plaiiitiff,-. : :und«r' S-'S-.oovenants ; iu : ; .th« :: ;lease>between' > l , ayne;;: and ' ! sC!: r'Celdwelly.-i fwas^giveii:;of > : the;;assign : ■ ...;.':■;'.;trar,.stating tKatHhe';tra'nifer.todefendant was ':!-.-. ,v;X regi*tefed;j • : ,s:Ccilinsel.'.f6r; ; ; .'defendant r contended; .;.--A*/.:tliat! : there- , was mo 'prpof .jthat'i defendant.^wae , ' ;vv>;; : ;:lieble;io. perform- the-cpyetjantsin: <XV Sssigriment St:y:: : hafe: Ji jß.b'e*h;fpfpducedvt 6rx(iis(iriified^cbpy, : ;by;i:he 'dis-. ; 'rff ; Svj .';'c«tifiedJcopr, ; :s^^ the l assign- ;'.:.-;,- mentifrom ■Caldwell'-.to'-defendant, was:either, •/:'>:-; of tthevassignniient; should-have-.been; '■¥5 : i proVed;V : > opinipn«of "the /Court ■■. pi -,v';.:"; .f : ,;^leas6 ; ;itelf;W:;'i%rtiM^cppy'vtherepf^ :y:3; ; ■^Sr. ; .ishowlwhether;.thetdefendant was liable. : t6' ; p'er?; .;,-."?;:.formiilve covenants,irivthe■ ori«mal■ lease!-}.such: ;fci^rtited^th^costgi'^SiOsiic^.j^':*::^r.;v,;fs

' ;■ ftJi , 6PpUMtipn'ofi , rouseLumberi'Ltdi{(Mr^Westbn)j ; , '5s for? rehearing Jof V.the ■' case: of '. John' 1 Macey/.'and: /,a?A]frMiGMtle:!(Mr^Neave);;v.^-;Pierard : ;and: i- a;; Brothers -f and -pf-zseyeral:. ..-;; ! .:;.oth'er.*aptibnsiagainst'/the.-Eamei : defendants 0~-..~i ■;■ The .applicants set'out':that .they werc'credU J4;i'tpre'?fpr^2s7/10s>t4df^as^iMtiyEade/Bros.-for : :^:S<amb'er,(euppJied::to ; them of-their 'i i ß/v.con , jaccr:forHhe.;;erecti'on-,:'ofca?dwelling' : for.,the' '." J -:\ .•defendant epplicante .commenced j/:':- antactiph::-id jthe ;Supreme;,Court c . for-ileayeVto ■' ;",.:>,';enforoi.itheifc''plaim'''against : .'ji.Nthey/had-given-Jnotice.lof.'lienjV^Thf.SuDrem ft.:Court;prbceedinM,--wer,e' !l at, ::,«,:l:;theferea,uest/bf |Eieifai , d'S;!soli6itbrs, t(T,,:enable: ■j'yr'liiie-texomple'telffiffler&tiSnSofc^n'elfietteerfUin' l .'- ;:-,;:;:;6elf.: '.iWhen .the hbuse:.:was Vcompleted, 'Pierard i=-;:paid; 4173- ?5..: sd; ( :iht6-the : /.-//-Wellington,'.;,: and- , :on:;:..February;: 2,: 1909,' ; Dr;; ;;;■;',and//Castle ■andlvnve/btfier-plaint'iffe, ■ divided! ?-'-'£ the- sum amongst; thenv-.jro; rata..::. In- :an; affi(■■(i davit.i-Wed'..-in--;tfe7.^fi^r* , ?' s -;:'P?"rt'-.>*n,6ii : . ii/S paying in, the I mphey;':Pierard; did--.not.-'aie6lb'se'. i:''.;/,".the;faot .that■PrpuserLumberivLtd.v'had:com- ';. >"- ; to'^haire^ii^. : . the,v<^^tr^iiti^-'.'./;af''--.•i-tbe | '?.:•:.;the'vaotionslwerefcoming: g^tfor":determination :.:l:v/ty r ,the C,ourt, and.-hence^were;riot;present;/'On '/: r 'A •tn<jseV.erpTU»dlF-»Hie3rv BjKedi/that'Jthß/.actions , be-rt.:>:reliear3.fi;U'J:?^*-/::ffe:?P::/A:/'^ ■/,:/>;~Aiter : .;i^:-IESue t ii.i.6onsiderablele'ngth,;his.Worship stated -'Kfitaat/Jit/Hppearedi.to'ihimfthat.'Prouse'iumbWi Hi:Altd^imftst;have: t khbwn v rthat/there:<were liens; ■;:. jjVinsM .Magistrate's Court.''; Moreover, ■ theiroini. ;:>';: tlienVtad-not J.'Tet...been; ;..and',:might;not; t be;' :. "?i'«tab!ißh^; : applicants! ■ ; / : .; ; / : might-..have.V-hie'"-Wbrship/vwast:-offppinion that•'/V* they/ conld their /present'appli-' ;.::.;>:catiohj-.Tyhicb^.' inust,bef.dismißsed.'j- .-:- . ; v--. , ; •.'