that she could not have gone out under more favourable circumstances than with her sister-in-law. The consideration of many friends enabled her though with a hesitating & sorrowful heart to leave her country with independence and comfort. I may mention that the most unexpected of her benefactors was Captain McDonald, the last I believe of the Inverere line, made her a present of £70 with a Bible of the late Miss McDonald's and giving me as he then understood greater expectations should I as he said himself leave my country. Uncle sent him your paper along with a letter of gratitude to which he replied so politely and kindly expressed his hope that Cath. might have a favourable passage and meet with & get a warm reception from her brothers of which she is most deserving. I shall anxiously look for your opinion of them both. I have no doubt but you will find Mrs M'Lean more the advantage in manner and refinement of mind but Cath most undoubtedly has clever and energetic abilities but perhaps Cath needs a little of that tact which renders conversation agreeable to all with whom we may come in contact but you however my dear brother you must make allowances for disadvantages and do not be too severe in your criticism. She is admirably suited for being with Alexander & Archy and will add no doubt to their enjoyment being naturally of a lively temperament but I suit the varied society which your popularity naturally involves you into. It would require a different style of person altogether but of this you will yourself be the best judge. You were very much fascinated with John's wife which makes me